To get everybody a redeemer just go to the bridge as early as possible to make it easier. I like round 10 . Now just have everyone use the axe until the start of round 14. DO NOT SHOOT. That is important. It will screw up getting the redeemer. Keep in mind that shooting only effects the player doing the shooting, nobody else. Also, throwing your redeemer into the pit with everybody simultaneously is a good idea but unnecessary. As soon as you get back on round 14 just go lob it in the pit. I've even used it for half a round then threw it in while back at the prison. If you go down before you can claim the redeemer, just throw your red one back in ASAP.